Introduction:
Comparison really is the thief of joy, and seeing your peers buy a property before you can often make you question why you're renting, but maybe home ownership isn't for you...
The decision between renting and buying a property is a pivotal choice that individuals and families face.
If you don't have the luxury of living rent-free or being given a large deposit to buy a home, you're probably wondering whether or not you should use your hard earned savings to rent or buy a home
In this post I'll shed light on the pros and cons of each option and exploring the idea that a property doesn't always have to be a home, and maybe it's beter off just as an income/cash-flowing asset
Renting:
Pros:
Flexibility: Renting provides the flexibility to move without the burden of selling a property, ending a rental agreement is alot more straightforward than selling a property you don't want the responsibility of anymore
Maintenance: Landlords typically bear the responsibility for property maintenance and repairs - when something breaks that you didn't purchase yourself, it's typically the landlord's responsibility to repair/change it
Lower Initial Costs: Renting often requires a smaller upfront financial commitment compared to buying - despite the increase in rental prices, the barrier to entry is still far lower than that of buying
Cons:
Lack of Equity: Renting does not build equity, meaning the tenant does not accumulate ownership in the property over time -
Rent Increases: Rental payments may increase over time, affecting long-term affordability - as you have seen with the inflationary environment we are currently in, a sudden spike in mortgage rates is often bad news for the tenant
Limited Personalisation: Renters may face restrictions on making significant changes to the property - you'll usually have to seek permission to make any major or minor changes to the property
Buying:
Pros:
Equity Building: Mortgage payments contribute to building equity, providing a long-term investment and the chance to benefit from capital appreciation over tiem
Stability: Homeownership offers a sense of stability and security - this is important for those with long time horizons and want to plan for decades not just a few years
Personalisation: Homeowners have the freedom to personalise and modify their living spaces (this can vary between leasehold and freehold, but generally speaking, you have more autonomy over your home)
Cons:
Financial Commitment: Buying involves a significant upfront cost, including a large deposit, taxes, legal fees, moving fees & more.
Responsibility for Maintenance: Homeowners are responsible for property maintenance and repairs. This goes with freehold houses too, there may be no designated service charge, but you still have pay for damages when they occur
Market Risks: Property values can fluctuate, affecting the potential return on investment - many people have found themselves in negative equity during downturns such as 2008 & 2023
Turning Property into an Income-Producing Asset:
In addition to dwelling on the decision to rent or buy, consider the idea that a property can be more than just a place to live—it can be an income-producing asset. This can be achieved through:
Renting Out a Portion: If your property has additional space, consider renting out a room or creating a separate unit for additional income.
Buy To Let: Buying a property purely for the purpose of renting it out to a tenant over a long period of time
Short-Term Rentals: Platforms like Airbnb allow homeowners to capitalize on short-term rentals for extra income.
Property Appreciation: Over time, your property may appreciate in value, providing an opportunity for a profitable sale. - UK House prices rose on average by 15% in the years between 2021 - 2022 - gains like this can be beneficial for raising money and reducing mortgage repayments
Example Scenario:
Renting vs. Buying a £400,000 Property
Let's break down the financial aspects of renting and buying a property valued at £400,000 with a 10% deposit over a 30-year term at a 5% interest rate.
Renting:
Monthly Rent: In this example we will assume a £400,000 property would rent for £1800 in today's market
Annual Rent: £21,600 (+bills & insurance)
Buying:
Property Price: £400,000.
10% Deposit: £40,000.
Mortgage Amount: £360,000.
Monthly Mortgage Payment: Approximately £1,932
Annual Mortgage Payment: £23,184.
As you can see here. it's near enough the same to rent & buy the property on a monthly basis, however, the costs involved in buying present a huge barrier.
Would that £40,000 be better off in another investment? You need to ask yourself what your long term goals are and consider all investment options available to you before buying a home
There is also the argument that renting is just "throwing money into a landlrod's pockets" - whilst this is true, there is also the consideration to make on the interest you are aying on the loan if you were to buy the property - not all of the repayment goes towards paying off the capital
With interest rates as high as they are, the majority of repayments actually go towards paying intrest and not capital. It's important to realise that the main financial benefits of homeownership are rooted in capital apreciation, so focusing on areas that have high projections for capital grwoth is crucial in maximising your savings/investments.
First Time Buyer Buy To let
It's also an option to consider buying a property to rent out. You can still purchase an investment property as a first time buyer. There are slightly more hurdles to jump through however
Higher Financial Hurdles: First-time buyers often face more stringent lending criteria from mortgage providers. Since they don't have a track record of managing a mortgage, lenders may perceive them as higher risk. This can mean higher interest rates, larger deposit requirements (often at least 30% or more of the property's value), and stricter income assessments.
Lack of Residential Mortgage History: Many lenders prefer to offer buy-to-let mortgages to individuals who already have a residential mortgage. This is because it demonstrates experience in managing mortgage repayments. First-time buyers, lacking this history, may find fewer lenders willing to offer them a buy-to-let mortgage.
Rental Income Assessment: Lenders will assess the potential rental income of the property to determine if it can sufficiently cover the mortgage payments. This is typically calculated as 125% to 145% of the mortgage payments at a ‘stress’ interest rate, which is higher than the actual rate. First-time buyers must prove that the rental income will be reliable and sufficient.
Credit History and Financial Stability: A strong credit history is crucial for first-time buyers. Lenders will closely scrutinize your financial stability, including your income, savings, debts, and credit score.
Property Type and Location: The choice of property and its location can significantly impact the rental yield and the property's appreciation over time. First-time buyers need to conduct thorough research to identify properties that are likely to attract steady rental demand.
For first-time buyers, stepping into the buy-to-let market requires careful planning, a solid understanding of the market they are buying in, and readiness to meet the responsibilities of being a landlord. It's a significant financial and time commitment, and should be approached with thorough research and professional advice.
Conclusion:
The decision to rent or buy depends on individual circumstances, financial goals, and lifestyle preferences. It's also important to work out the costs of both as you might find renting ends up being a cheaper and more financially prudent option than buying if you are able to put your savings to better use.
When making the decision, work out whether you'd like to buy a property for yourself to live in or a property to rent out. You might find renting and buying an investment prperty suits your goals better.
Get In Touch
Get in touch with us to discuss your mortgage options today www.propertypurchaser.xyz/mortgages
Comments